Meet The Team

Cindy Carlisle

Cindy is a native of Rockford, Illinois. After receiving her Masters of Divinity from McCormick Theological Seminary, she served as Associate Pastor for Youth, Young Adults and Children in Baraboo, Wisconsin; Interim Pastor in Mineral Ridge; and Temporary Supply Pastor in Niles, Ohio. Prior to ordination, she held positions in the field of criminal justice including corrections, research, and victim services. Cindy loves spending time with her family – her husband Dave and children Erica, Elizabeth and Ben. Cindy enjoys reading (especially teen fiction), ballroom dancing, sailing and scuba diving.

Rev. Cindy CarlisleInterim Pastor
Jodine Pilmer

Jodine grew up in Trinity Presbyterian Church, a predecessor of the New Lisbon Presbyterian Church. There, she learned to play the organ, instructed by Marshall Bailey of Salem, and went on to Westminster College, Pa., to continue organ studies with Raymond Ocock, while pursuing a degree in Music Education. She taught in public schools in New Jersey, Maryland and Lisbon, and spent some time as a journalist at the Morning Journal. In addition to her position as Music Director at NLPC, she serves as musical director for area theatres and schools. She lives at Guilford Lake and enjoys cooking and traveling.

Jodine PilmerMusic Director